David "Dumbass" Horowitz at UCI

.....From the OC Weekly: DAVID HOROWITZ AT UCI LAST NIGHT:

.....David Horowitz descended on UCI last night as part of his nationwide tour condemning a national student group called Muslim Student Association – a group with more than 150 chapters in colleges all over the country.
.....Horowitz, a famous right wing nut jobber, is famous for taking out provocative full page ads in campus newspapers that say things like Black people don't deserve reparations for slavery, in advance of his speaking engagements during Black History Month, which would then cause all kinds of static to the school paper. In some cases protesters or school administrators would admonish the paper for printing the incendiary ad, which would prompt Horowitz to say it is an example of censorship on university campuses.
…..
.....Once in the lecture room at Rowland Hall, the first thing I noticed was it was sparsely populated, mostly with people 50 and over. There were about 40 audience members total, scattered in seats throughout the lecture room. The room was a minimalist theater style setting with white undecorated walls and ceiling, and puke inducing overhead fluorescent lighting. At the front of the room was a obviously photoshopped poster of a hijabed Muslim woman holding a sign that says "God Bless Hitler" in English?
.....Horowitz is droning on about something in a beige suit with red undershirt. His voice is raspy and he's got a bottle of Aquafina. If I didn't know better, I would say he looks either half drunk, or hung over.
.....He says Muslim student groups all over the United States are being trained to kill us in our own schools, "We're providing technology to people who's ideology is that we are the devil and they have to blow us up," he says.
…..
.....During the question and answer phase, one bright young student relayed a story of how he has also endured suffering.
....."I'm a history student and I've had the misfortune of having taken an Chicano studies course," he lamented. "The whole course was learning about these no name activists and these brown berets and whatever. The only reason I took it was because it was the only class that fit my schedule."
....."Thugs," Horowitz replies….

Professor fired by university for having standards

.....From this morning’s Inside Higher Ed: Students Fail — and Professor Loses Job:

.....Who is to blame when students fail? If many students fail — a majority even — does that demonstrate faculty incompetence, or could it point to a problem with standards?
.....These are the questions at the center of a dispute that cost Steven D. Aird his job teaching biology at Norfolk State University. Today is his last day of work, but on his way out, he has started to tell his story — one that he suggests points to large educational problems at the university and in society. The university isn’t talking publicly about his case, but because Aird has released numerous documents prepared by the university about his performance — including the key negative tenure decisions by administrators — it is clear that he was denied tenure for one reason: failing too many students. The university documents portray Aird as unwilling to compromise to pass more students.
.....A subtext of the discussion is that Norfolk State is a historically black university with a mission that includes educating many students from disadvantaged backgrounds. The university suggests that Aird — who is white — has failed to embrace the mission of educating those who aren’t well prepared. But Aird — who had backing from his department and has some very loyal students as well — maintains that the university is hurting the very students it says it wants to help. Aird believes most of his students could succeed, but have no incentive to work as hard as they need to when the administration makes clear they can pass regardless.
.....“Show me how lowering the bar has ever helped anyone,” Aird said in an interview. Continuing the metaphor, he said that officials at Norfolk State have the attitude of “a track coach who tells the team ‘I really want to win this season but I really like you guys, so you can decide whether to come to practice and when.’ ” Such a team wouldn’t win, Aird said, and a university based on such a principle would not be helping its students.
…..
.....Aird points to a Catch-22 that he said hinders professors’ ability to help students. Because so many students come from disadvantaged backgrounds and never received a good high school education, they are already behind, he said, and attendance is essential. Norfolk State would appear to endorse this point of view, and official university policy states that a student who doesn’t attend at least 80 percent of class sessions may be failed.
.....The problem, Aird said, is that very few Norfolk State students meet even that standard. In the classes for which he was criticized by the dean for his grading — classes in which he awarded D’s or F’s to about 90 percent of students — Aird has attendance records indicating that the average student attended class only 66 percent of the time. Based on such a figure, he said, “the expected mean grade would have been an F,” and yet he was denied tenure for giving such grades.
.....Other professors at Norfolk State, generally requesting anonymity, confirmed that following the 80 percent attendance rule would result frequently in failing a substantial share — in many cases a majority — of their students. Professors said attendance rates are considerably lower than at many institutions — although most institutions serve students with better preparation.
.....One reason that this does not happen (outside Aird’s classes) is that many professors at Norfolk State say that there is a clear expectation from administrators — in particular from Dean Sandra J. DeLoatch, the dean whose recommendation turned the tide against Aird’s tenure bid — that 70 percent of students should pass.
.....Aird said that figure was repeatedly made clear to him and he resisted it. Others back his claim privately. For the record, Joseph C. Hall, a chemistry professor at president of the Faculty Senate, said that DeLoatch “encouraged” professors to pass at least 70 percent of students in each course, regardless of performance. Hall said that there is never a direct order given, but that one isn’t really needed.
…..
.....DeLoatch … rejected the relevance of 16 letters in Aird’s portfolio from students who praised him as a teacher. The students, some of whom are now in medical or graduate school or who have gone on to win research awards, talked about his extra efforts on their behalf, how he had been a mentor, and so forth. DeLoatch named each student in the review, and noted their high grade point averages and various successes. Some of the students writing on his behalf received grades as low as C, although others received higher grades.
…..
.....Aird stressed that he does not believe Norfolk State should try to become an elite college. He said he believes that only about 20 percent of the students who enroll truly can’t do the work. He believes another 20 percent are ready from the start. Of the middle 60 percent, he said that when the university tells them that substandard work and frequent class skipping are OK, these students are doomed to fail his courses (and not to learn what they need from other professors).
.....“I think most of the students have the intellectual capacity to succeed, but they have been so poorly trained, and given all the wrong messages by the university,” he said.
.....The problem at Norfolk State, he said, isn’t his low grades, but the way the university lowers expectations. He noted that in the dean’s negative review of his tenure bid, nowhere did she cite specific students who should have received higher grades, or subject matter that shouldn’t have been in his courses or on his tests. The emphasis is simply on passing students, he said.
.....“If everyone here would tell students that ‘you are either going to work or get out,’ they would work, and they would blossom,” he said. “We’ve got to present a united front — high academic standards in all classes across the institution. Some students will bail, and we can’t help those, but the ones who stay will realize that they aren’t going to be given a diploma for nothing, and that their diploma means something.”….

.....It seems to me that many of us in the community colleges, as instructors, face some version of Aird's dilemma. Many students do not attend classes regularly enough, and they don't do the work they should be doing for their courses. If we were to apply the standards that we in some sense ought to be applying, most of our students would receive Ds and Fs. Meanwhile, the colleges encourage (or they do absolutely nothing to discourage) the idea that students can hold jobs and have active social lives while taking perhaps 4 or 5 courses. There is indeed something wrong with the "system."
.....I try to encourage good attendance and homework by assigning semi-weekly written assignments. (Naturally, these take many hours to grade.) I tell students that they must complete the assignments (adequately) in order to receive a non-F grade in the course. (80% is where, supposedly, I draw the line.) I constantly remind them of this rule. I even give them chances to make up assignments they've missed.
.....I would estimate that the average rate at which students complete these assignments is below 50%.