Thursday, December 31, 2009

1982: The district hires Larry Stevens and learns to regret it


More SOCCCD history.

This story centers on Larry P. Stevens, that other awful Chancellor, and his stormy three-year tenure. The faculty's struggle to send Stevens packing reached its conclusion six months before I was hired at IVC, and so I came to this saga with no understanding but with a vague sense that Chancellor troubles are nothing new to the district.

What follows is based entirely on abstracts of old LA Times articles. (That’s right; I’m too cheap to pay for the articles themselves. There's like twenty of 'em.) Hence, the following account is full of gaps, some minor, some major. I'm hoping that some of them can be filled by readers. The most notable gap? Just what did Chancellor Stevens say at that assembly in November of 1982 that got people so riled?

Please note: the dates in parentheses are dates of source Times articles (i.e., abstracts).

Late 1982

Larry Stevens was hired as Chancellor of the Saddleback Community College District (SCCD) in September of 1982.

Stevens had been “president of Tacoma Community College in Washington before coming to Saddleback. In the late 1970s and early '80s, he was the target of faculty criticism—and a vote of no confidence—at that college” (2/19/85).

One report indicated that the “friction” between Stevens and SCCCD faculty “first surfaced in November, 1982…, when he addressed a faculty assembly…” (2/19/85).

(Gosh. Just what did he say?)

Evidently, Stevens “probed” issues in ways that were objectionable to some. E.g., he sought “more expansion land for fast-growing Saddleback College” (7/16/85).

1983

By 1983, the faculty union, led by Sharon MacMillan, charged that Stevens “’hired cronies,’ wasted money on administrative frills and was dictatorial” (11/4/85).

To complicate matters, starting in July of 1983, faculty were working without a contract (2/19/85).

During this period, the board of trustees comprised Eugene McKnight, William Watts, Robert Price, and Robert Moore. (Don’t know who the other three were.)

Stevens weighed in on the big "fees" debate, 5-24-84, Tustin News
1984

At the March 1984 board meeting, faculty of the district “called for the board of trustees to fire Chancellor Larry P. Stevens.” In a press conference held just before the meeting, faculty union president MacMillan reported that Stevens had suffered an overwhelming vote of no confidence (90%) (3/27/84).

The board refused to comply with faculty wishes. In response, faculty eventually “sought to recall three trustees who consistently supported [Stevens]” (11/4/85). Watts, Price, and Moore were targeted.

The recall effort was announced in early May of 1984 (5/4/84).

Soon thereafter, Stevens “rebuked” the union for pursuing a recall of board members (5/8/84).

In October, “Four Saddleback Community College District Trustees not named as recall targets …  condemned the recall threat and supported their three targeted colleagues” (10/28/84).

Union leaders denied that difficult contract negotiations were the reason for the recalls. The recalls concerned Stevens, not salaries (11/3/84).

"An accreditation team described the overloads as 'very heavy' and
recommended the practice 'should be examined to determine if
there is an adverse effect on the quality of education.'" (Tustin News, 5-17-84)
5-24-84, Tustin News
1985

The faculty contract was settled in February of ’85.

“Despite the overwhelming approval of the [contract] agreement, [Robert Kopfstein] said the union will continue to seek the recall of three college district trustees” (2/26/85).

“Effort to Recall Trustees Fails for Lack of Signatures” (5/30/85).

(On July 1, 1985, Saddleback College “North Campus” became the autonomous “Irvine Valley College,” Saddleback's sister college.)

“South County Veteran Saddleback Trustee to Step Down” (7/16/85).

Trustee McKnight was not running for reelection, and so the faculty union sought to fill his seat (in the Nov. ‘85 special election) with someone more to their liking (11/1/85).

“Mike Eggers, an aide to Rep. Ron Packard (R-Carlsbad), [was] among four candidates for [Eugene McKnight]'s seat. Eggers … clashed with the teachers' union and accused it of being behind a mailer … that accused him of unethical behavior and links to an alleged ‘racketeer.’ Eggers said the accusations were ‘lies’” (11/4/85).

In the end, though the 1985 recall effort failed (too few signatures), the union’s goals for the November ('85) election were successful. Watts and Price were gone. (Moore was not up for reelection.) McKnight was replaced with a union-friendly trustee (who?).  Both Iris Swanson and Marcia Milchiker became trustees in this election. (Swanson died in 1993 and was replaced by Teddi Lorch.)

At that point, the union had the votes it needed to get Stevens fired.

The salary debate, 5-17-84, Tustin News


1986

Stevens announced his resignation in January of 1986.

At the time, Bill Watts, opined: “I think [the faculty’s] biggest complaint is that Larry Stevens expected them to work five days a week"(1/8/86). McKnight spoke of a “communication problem” between Stevens and faculty.

“Faculty in the Coast Community College District [sic], after failing at a recall, succeeded in electing three union-endorsed trustees, who became the new board majority. The incumbent chancellor, whom the union opposed, resigned a week after those elections” (1/8/86).

The terms of Stevens’ resignation were that “neither the trustees nor Stevens would issue any ‘negative comments’ about each other” (1/8/86).

Upon Stevens’ exit, executive Vice Chancellor (of Educational Services and Student Development) David Habura served as acting chancellor (2/26/86).

Eventually, Richard Sneed succeeded Stevens as Chancellor.

* * * *

In 1986, Stevens became “Assistant Professor of Administration, Rehabilitation and Postsecondary Education” at San Diego State U. He retired in 1991. He came out of retirement to set up Cascadia Community College. He then worked in accreditation until 2001. He is again retired.

Comments:

Bob Cosgrove said...


When Stevens was interviewed he indicated that he taught communication courses but no one followed up on that until I requested a copy of his dissertation. In the blurb that we all write about ourselves, he indicated that he taught in (I believe) an elementary school. He was not quite as forthright as he claimed. The FA [faculty union] made copies of the self assessment page from his dissertation. There was a brief period of embarrassment for him and some BOT members. The dissertation was not well written and typical of bad education degrees of that time.

7:45 PM, January 01, 2010

P.S.: found this:

Saddleback College Faculty's Actions, LA Times, Apr 29, 1984

     Recently, I have been drastically disturbed by the lack of professionalism and, more important, the lack of objectivity demonstrated by some of my fellow faculty members at Saddleback College. Some have rushed to judgment without having researched the facts related to administrative leadership by Chancellor Larry Stevens.
     An essential ingredient of any teaching learning process is objectivity. I would have to assign an F grade to the recent conduct of some of the Saddleback College faculty for their lack of objectivity in asking the board of trustees to discharge its recently selected chancellor.
     Stevens’ actions since assuming the role of chancellor have been evaluated and praised by many objective groups, including the Western Assn. of Schools and Colleges [the accreditor].
     In its evaluation, that body made a number of recommendations. Dr. Stevens embarked on programs to make those improvements.
     One program Dr. Stevens improved was that of affirmative action. Historically, Saddleback College has been criticized and sued for discrimination in its hiring policies. Recently, the board, with the leadership of Dr. Stevens, strengthened its affirmative action program and policies. As a result Saddleback College has welcomed to its administration three very capable females: Dr. Maria Sheehan, a Hispanic, who was elevated to vice chancellor; Constance Carroll, a black, who was recently installed as president of South Campus, and Marley Bergerud, who heads the South Campus Business Science Division.
     For these and other improvements, the students and taxpayers of this district owe Dr. Larry Stevens a debt of gratitude and support. I call upon my fellow faculty members to accept a position of reconciliation so that together we can work to offer quality education to people of all ages.

JACK BYERLY

Lake Forest

History question: who argued that college Poli Sci professors should teach the Board’s political views? Guess!


Orange Union High, 1920. Now: Chapman U

During my historical internet wanderings this morning, I came across an odd claim somebody made about Tom "bagman" Fuentes, one of the SOCCCD's arch-conservative trustees. It was something about Tom's view regarding what college Poli Sci instructors should teach, expressed back in 1993.

I did some Googling and quickly found what I was looking for. The info I needed was in a small piece,  appearing just days before the disastrous 2000 election, by our old pal Matt Coker of the OC Weekly: Ralph crammed in (11/02/00).

Nearly four months after Holocaust denier Steve Frogue’s resignation from the SOCCCD board of trustees and then-OC GOP chair Tom Fuentes’ highly hinky appointment as replacement (by our all-Republican board), the infamous Bush/Gore Presidential race was in full swing.

You’ll recall that, unfortunately, famed consumer advocate Ralph Nader was in that race, drawing progressive votes from Mr. Gore. At the time, many (not me) worried that Nader would insure a Bush victory. Well, as you know, that’s just what happened.

In late October of 2000, somehow, the local Green Party managed to hold a rally for Ralphy Boy at Chapman U’s Memorial Hall (Oct. 20). In his report, Matt explained all that and then turned his attention to an incident involving Fuentes:
Chapman political-science department chairman Fred Smoller was instrumental in bringing Nader to the Orange campus. But before the rally, he talked to us about Tom Fuentes, grand wizard of the Orange County Republican Party. Fuentes was recently appointed to fill an unexpired term on the South Orange County Community College District board of trustees, which oversees Saddleback and Irvine Valley colleges.

Fuentes' campaign for a full term on the board alarms Smoller, who recalled a bizarre phone call he got seven years ago in which the GOP henchman and Chapman alum apparently said that political-science professors should teach the views of their college's board of trustees—Chapman's board is composed mostly of conservatives. While Fuentes was "soundly rebuffed by the [university's] provost," Smoller is frightened that Fuentes may wind up foisting his "anti-academic" perspective on academics.

Fuentes could not be reached for comment, but Mark Petracca, UC Irvine's political-science department chairman, said it's common for professors to teach from the perspective of their college's governing board—at "small, liberal-arts, Christian schools where the value we generally place on academic freedom is not so well-respected. But at any major-league university, that kind of censorship would not be tolerated. It'd just be ridiculous."

How about at public colleges? Petracca burst into laughter before saying, "It's easy to imagine groups of government bodies—boards of trustees, regents or the state legislature—getting upset at someone for something she says, something she writes, or something she teaches. But no one tries to do anything about it. And I'm fairly certain if somebody tried, the reaction would be pretty severe." ….
I missed that one. But Wow. (Petracca is [or at least was!] a big fan of this blog.)

Roy's obituary in LA Times and Register: "we were lucky to have you while we did"

  This ran in the Sunday December 24, 2023 edition of the Los Angeles Times and the Orange County Register : July 14, 1955 - November 20, 2...